Home arrow Opinions arrow Leave Americans in Mexico Be
Apr 11 2007
Leave Americans in Mexico Be | Print |  E-mail
Op_ed
By MWC News   

Translation

Leave Americans in Mexico Be
by Jacob G. Hornberger, guest columnist

ImageThere is a big immigration problem that has been growing year after year. An increasing number of American citizens are moving to Mexico, and some of them are even becoming undocumented workers. Even worse, they are refusing to assimilate and are even insisting on retaining their U.S. citizenship.

Six years ago, on February 5, 2001, in an article entitled "American Retirees Flock to a 'Paradise' in Mexico," the Washington Post reported that in the small Mexican town of Anjijic, where 7,500 Americans lived, there was a banner just past the Gringo Grill that in English read, "Welcome to your new home." Bringing their culture to Mexico, the Americans in Anjijic were organizing gardening classes and Sunday morning walking clubs. The Lake Chapala Society had a library containing 20,000 books -- in English -- and an English-language theater. The Super Lake market carried rye bread and every type of Betty Crocker cake mix. Restaurant menus in town were changing from enchiladas to waffles for breakfast. Most of the people at Donas Donuts were Americans, discussing U.S. political issues, presumably in English.

Since then the problem has only intensified. That 2001 article reported that the U.S. Embassy estimated that 600,000 Americans were living in Mexico. Today, Wikipedia puts the number at one million.

The assimilation problem has gotten any better either. In a recent article entitled "Illegal Gringos," the Los Angeles Times reported that San Miguel de Allende, Mexico, has many retired baby boomers moving into town, a number of whom are performing work without a permit or license. It's obvious that they're not even bothering to learn Spanish because there is an expatriate newspaper oriented toward them that is written in English. Yes, you read that right -- a local English-language newspaper in the heart of Mexico for Americans living there!

There are undoubtedly some people who are condemning all this as something despicable, perhaps even immoral. "I think it's horrible that they've retained allegiance to the United States," they no doubt are saying. "They should become Mexican citizens. Why aren't they assimilating? Why aren't they learning Spanish? They're taking jobs away from Mexicans. They're still flying the American flag, and they're singing the Star Spangled Banner. They're celebrating the Fourth of July more than the Cinco de Mayo. Worst of all, they're actually rooting for American sports teams rather than Mexican ones. Something needs to be done about these people!"

I say, leave those Americans alone. Why shouldn't they be free to live in Mexico any way they want? If they want to associate only with other Americans, why shouldn't they be free to do so? Why should they be required to give up their American citizenship just because they're living in Mexico? Sure, it might be a good idea for them to learn Spanish, but shouldn't this be left up to them? And yes, some of them are working illegally, but who cares? Aren't they providing services that people are willing to pay for and that are improving people's lives? And so what if they're still flying the American flag, singing the Star Spangled Banner, and celebrating the Fourth of July? Who are they hurting? And does it really matter that they're rooting for American sports teams instead of Mexican ones?

Leave Americans in Mexico be. Let them pursue happiness in their own way. Isn't that what freedom is all about?

Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org).

Recommend this article...




Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Newsvine!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Quote this article on your site | Views: 3446

Comments (8)
RSS comments
1. 11-04-2007 12:39
you're wrong
They should assimilate, learn the language, honor local traditions, or get out. Flying their flag, speaking their native language, and observing their old traditions will be taken as an affront and build resentment. And rightly so. 
I certainly resent those very same actions in Mexicans in the US, and consider them disrespectful. You want to retire to Mexico? Great. Become a citizen, and accept that your old culture now needs to be replaced with the Mexican culture.
Guest
2. 11-04-2007 13:28
you're wrong
I have lived in San Miguel de Allende for the past twenty years plus. I do speak Spanish, I do have permission to work, I do pay Mexican taxes and honor their customs & traditions. I am an exception in these things but there are many of us exceptions!
Guest
iconoclast@pobox.comNOSPAM! ">John J Sullivan
3. 11-04-2007 17:42
you're wrong
Retired Americans in Mexico -- i.e. older folks, like older Mexicans in the US, all have problems in learning the prevalant language. We should be cognizant of this, and not pressure them to do something which they just usually cannot do, or at least not do well. And that's true both sides of the border. But Americans in Mexico do bring money which means jobs for many who would otherwise not have one.
Guest
cfw123@gmail.comNOSPAM! ">Charles Wilkes
4. 11-04-2007 17:57
Call out Mexico's Minutemen
Now I know why my gym is infested with elderly stairmaster and water aerobics enthusiasts. They're getting revved up to run for the border (and climb and swim, as required). As someone who has splashed to the side of the pool halfway through a workout, to hang on in humiliated, gasping exhaustion while people fifty years my senior churned effortlessly through another round of backward arm curls, I fully appreciate the danger to Mexico's security these elderly invaders represent. And who knows how many members of the dreaded, militant AARP lurk among them?
Guest
Lou
5. 11-04-2007 21:01
Call out Mexico's Minutemen
There are indeed some ugly Americans living in Mexico. I'm a 66-year-old semi-retired American. Two months ago, I moved to Chapala, just a few miles down the road from Ajijic -- the focal point of the article above. 
 
During my first week here, I was having lunch at a very good, and typical, restaurant in Ajijic. At a nearby table, there were three American women, in their fifties and sixties, talking about their maids. I was eavesdropping, listening to their converstation, although they were so loud it would have been difficult to ignore what was being said. They were actually bragging and competing, trying to top each other, as to who was paying the least for their maids. When they said "my maid" it was condescending, almost venemous.  
 
For me, this was a poor and fortunately inaccurate introduction to the gringos in Mexico. Since then, I have met many other retired Americans (and Canadians, Brits, Germans, French, Danes and Belgians) who are quietly doing wonderful things for their new Mexican friends and neighbors. 
 
I have already met a half-dozen retired expats who teach English for no pay at elementary and high schools. I've met retired expat nurses who counsel Mexican women after mastectomies (I don't yet know why, but there appears to be a high incidence of breast cancer in this area of Mexico). And, I know of a half-dozen retired expat couples who volunteer a couple of days each week to help some old, very old, nuns who manage an underfunded orphanage. 
 
Most of the white expats I've met have a genuine respect for the Mexicans and their culture. Most of the expats make an attempt to learn to speak Spanish, with mixed success, but the Mexicans seem to appreciate their attempts. 
 
I don't speak Spanish yet, but I'm confident that within a few months I will learn enough to be polite and show respect for a country and culture in which I am a guest. Today, at the large supermarket in Chapala, the check-out clerk asked me (in Spanish) if I had my fidelity card. (What are those things called? You know, the card that gives points and discounts based on purchase volume). I wanted to tell her that I forgot my card, but I didn't know the word. So, I asked in Spanish, "How does one say 'forgot'?" She then gave me a brief Spanish lesson. There was a Mexican family in line behind me. Instead of being annoyed by being delayed by my Spanish lesson, they joined in the conversation to help with my language lesson. Very friendly and wonderful people. 
 
Not counting military and US government employees, there are between four and eight million Americans living outside the US -- nobody really knows how many. There are an estimated one million Americans in Mexico. My experience and observations tell me that the primary reason Americans are becoming expats is because it is the best lifestyle they can afford. Among other things, I know for certain that many Americans prefer the medical care they receive in Mexico, even when they have medical coverage back in the states. 
 
Before coming to Mexico, I lived in France for four years -- on the French Riviera, strething my Social Security Check until the dollar/euro exchange rate made that impossible. I like France and the French people, but I know that I will develop a similar affection for the Mexicans.
Guest
6. 12-04-2007 07:44
Call out Mexico's Minutemen
Build a damn wall and keep them in their places. Who the hell do they think they are?! (Sound familiar?)
Guest
znzfqlxskj@gmail.comNOSPAM! ">james secor
7. 16-04-2007 12:09
San Miguel Is Ex-Patriate Village
:grin Of course San Miguel is a haven for ex-patriates. It has been since the GI bill after WWII allowed servicemen and wives to move down and study with the mere pittance given to pursue their life and interests. If it were not for the Americans in SMA, it would be very slow with an economy that could not support the local population. The number of ex-patriates is rising in SMA, but nothing like the numbers of ex-patriate Mexicans who cross the border to the North to assimilate with America's suggested way of life. If you can afford to live in one of the great Mexican American retirement communities and you can mix with the locals without making the area another MacDonalds laden waste area, than I sulpport the wonderful Baby Boomers Exit...especially when not every born American is particularly happy with how the American lifestyle plays out these days. I lived in SMA for nearly nine years, when I worked as an International Tour Guide. Now that I am heading into the mainstream of retired grey haired Americans, I can't wait to figure out how I can join the good life that I left when I departed from San Miguel nearly 30 years ago. Like my buddy, the late Mr. Jaime Morris, I hope I can add something to the unique setting and life that this little vilge offers the fortunate few Boomers. MMc
Guest
medimaxlines@yahoo.comNOSPAM! ">Mac McCloud
8. 06-07-2007 03:25
Healthcare - who pays?
As an employee of a community hospital who has a laarge percentage of Charity Care (NJ's healthcare system does not designate public hospitals but expects every one to take on indigent and uninsured persons), I know that one of the issues we have is with illegal immigrants who use our government provided services and do not pay taxes. I know little about the Mexican healthcare system, but I wondered how these expats pay for medical care they use. THe imbalance in the US is that healthcare is a right that all enjoy but some do not fund. I have no defense for the role that big pharma and insurnace companies play but wanted to share a thought.
Guest
bonkiliki@gmail.comNOSPAM! ">Brady Wine

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:

Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.4


Tags:  Jacob G. Hornberger Americans Mexico
 
< Prev Content   Next Content >
 

Translate

Enter Amount:

toolbar powered by Conduit