Home arrow Commentary arrow OPINIONS arrow op-ed arrow Gun-free Zone
Apr 18 2007
Gun-free Zone | Print |  E-mail
Op_ed
By MWC NEWS   

Translation

Once Again, Gun Control Doesn't Work
by Jacob G. Hornberger

ImageTo belabor the obvious, murderers do not obey restrictions on gun possession, contrary to the long-repeated suggestion of the gun-control crowd -- that if we simply enact such restrictions into law, murderers will comply with them.

As we once again see in the context of the Virginia Tech massacre, a person who intends to break a law against murder isn't going to stop and say to himself, "Oh my, I can't use a gun to commit these murders because the school's regulations prevent me from carrying a gun onto campus."

Virginia Tech, a state school, prohibits its students from carrying guns onto campus. When someone recently introduced a bill in the Virginia legislature to permit students with state-issued concealed-carry permits to carry guns onto campus, the bill was allowed to die in committee.

So there you have it, once again: Virginia Tech's gun-control regulation disarmed Virginia Tech's students from defending themselves against a mass murderer who, having ignored the regulation, could be virtually certain that all Virginia Tech students would be disarmed. Why, just one or two armed students could have taken the murderer out.

Virginia Tech officials steadfastly maintain that their "gun-free zone" makes their campus safer. Yeah, safer for mass murderers who know that they won't have to worry about students with the capacity to fire back.

The gun controllers have a second rationale for gun control -- that with harshly enforced gun-control laws, guns would disappear from the marketplace and, therefore, murderers would be unable to acquire guns. You know, sort of like drug laws, which, as everyone knows, have caused illicit drugs to disappear from the marketplace, thereby preventing drug users from acquiring them.

The problem is that the gun-control crowd has never heard of -- or at least never understood -- a free-market phenomenon known as the "black market." It is an illegal market that immediately arises whenever the government criminalizes a peaceful activity, such as the consumption of drugs or ownership of guns. Moreover, as we have learned in the drug war (and during Prohibition), the black market inevitably generates collateral violence, which the government then uses as the excuse for more intervention and control.

We should note also that gun controllers hardly ever confront the original and central purpose of the Second Amendment: To serve as a check against tyranny. Their position here, which is as faulty and fallacious as their other two gun-control positions, is that, unlike the olden days, the federal government can now be trusted never to become tyrannical.

How many gun massacres must we witness before Americans finally abandon their devotion to gun control? The best thing Americans could ever do is to abolish all restrictions on ownership of weapons, including registration requirements, waiting periods, concealed-carry laws, et cetera, which would once again permit ordinary, peaceful, law-abiding Americans the unrestricted ability to defend themselves against murderers, who have as much respect for laws against guns as they do for laws against murder.

Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org).

Recommend this article...




Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Newsvine!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Quote this article on your site | Views: 1263

Comments (4)
RSS comments
1. 18-04-2007 20:15
Excellent. No law would have stopped this massacre. Much of the gun violence in the US is due to gangs because of black market drugs. The Federal Government has become more powerful and corrupt than ever. Citizens must not be disarmed.
Guest
2. 18-04-2007 21:37
Weapon is not a solution
The solution to stop something like this is not to turn a campus to Wild West and allow everyone to carry concealed weapon.  
 
What good that will do?  
 
Unless you have pre-knowledge of an attack, it is impossible to defend yourself with a gun.  
 
Gun was made for offensive purposes not defensive. 
 
You cannot defy the law of physics. By the time you take out your concealed weapon and release the safety pin, you are already dead. 
 
Let us assume some students they had guns in this incident, start shooting, and let’s say all were better trained then military and would not shoot others by mistake. 
 
What would happen after the police gets there? Watching bunch of students shooting, they don’t know who the perpetrator is.  
 
Probable result?  
 
We cannot be sure exactly but it's safe to assume the casualties would be much higher then 33 people.
Registered
3. 21-04-2007 07:02
Weapon is not a solution
I am somewhat disturbed that the horrific tragedy at Virginia Tech has left me strangely unmoved. That is not exactly correct. I am in some respects resentful of the way the event is being mourned and am even seemingly unmoved by the tears of the fellow students and the parents of the victims. I am actually ashamed of the hardness of my heart in this matter.  
 
I first became aware of these feelings while listening to the eulogy for the victims being delivered by George W. Bush. Once again, this intellectual realization/reaction was the last - the slowest to emerge. The first was a visceral aversion to the president’s words. Of course his remarks and even his presence at the memorial service was strictly pro forma, had Bill Clinton or Jimmy Carter been president, exactly the same speech would have been delivered. Listening to this man, who will go to his reward with the souls of perhaps a million around his neck, I could not help but be reminded of the remark that “kill one and you are a murderer; kill a thousand and you are a hero.” To my mind hearing Bush’s heartfelt, comforting remarks was the same as if I were listening to Pol Pat. Here is the supreme irony of a man, who will be judged by history as one of its biggest mass murderers, comforting the victims of a deeply tormented, deranged, lone psychotic who, thanks to the guns virtually placed in his hands by our “free enterprise system”, committed an act of comparative insignificance. May the gods forgive the psychopaths, great and small, for they know not what they do. 
 
The other day we killed 300 Iraqis. No, not exactly. They were the victims of insurgents’ attacks in response and in reaction to our presence there. In the law, crimes committed in conjunction with a crime and crimes facilitated by a crime and crimes committed as a subsequent result of a crime must be laid at the feet of the perpetrator of the original offence. Hence I say we killed 300 Iraqis the other day.  
 
Now I realize that people in America are devastated far more by the murders of the 32 than the 300. Even Tony Soprano knows it is a rule of human consciousness to count our family, friends and members of our tribe as possessing far more importance than strangers (twelve thousand miles away). For the rest of us, who possess a little more geographical and emotional distance from Virginia, both crime scenes posses a degree of abstraction that might perhaps give us more objectivity and a chance to see an equal level of global humanity.  
 
I am sure that I am not the only one who has wept over the deaths of the six hundred thousand plus innocent Iraqi men, women and children we have murdered since we began the rape of this small, defenseless country. This is partially because I have made a conscious effort to be impacted by the stories and the photographs of the Iraqi victims. This has taken a nearly ghoul-like obsessive search for unspeakably horrific photographs and accounts far from the headlines – not recommended for more sensitive viewers. Unlike the Vietnam war where Americans were nightly bombarded with scenes of atrocity and carnage, the Iraqi conflict has been effectively sanitized for our protection. We see the rifles shooting, bombs dropping and the missiles firing, but most Americans believe with Werner Von Braun, “Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down? That\\\\\\\'s not my department.”  
 
I have deliberately chosen to make these distant, unknown victims my family, my friends and I have also chosen to respond more authentically to these deaths than even deaths like the VT students. I can claim only the most distant sense of responsibility for the tragic deaths of the 32. I can however, as a citizen, in whose name my government is contributing to this slaughter, claim a much higher degree of responsibility, guilt, shame and grief. For me, it is imperative that I use most of my pity for the Iraqi deaths, not for the brave but criminal soldiers fighting so illegally or yes, even for the victims of our own senselessness worship of these metallic phallus substitutes that we Americans refuse to stop fondling. 
 
Sometimes the madness of my fellow citizens makes me so distraught that I want to run screaming into the street. You know what the latest spin on the VT massacre is? Pundits are blaming it on the ABSANCE of guns on campus. Yes the absence of guns. It seems there is a ban on concealed weapons in effect there. The logic goes something like this. If the other students in the class were packing, when the gunman showed up, he would have been blown away. They actually assert that as gun ownership goes up, examples of gun related violence goes down.  
 
Back in the seventies, iconic knuckle-dragger, Archie Bunker - paterfamilias of the TV show All in the Family, came to embody the quintessential ditto-head mentality of Rush Limbaugh. One of his more outrageous approaches to airline hijacking was a suggestion that, upon boarding, each passenger be issued a handgun. In the seventies, this was laughable. Sadly, that is no longer the case. It is amazing how the right wing gun nuts are now using this same argument in light of the VT tragedy to restrict further even present, permissive gun laws. Only this time it is no joke.  
 
Bob Boldt
Guest
Bob Boldt
4. 22-04-2007 06:35
Weapon is not a solution
Bob Boldt expressed it perfectly of what many feel. It\'s my sentiments exactly. On another note, the US warmongering has desensitized many through the media, movies, commercials, cartoons, and toys. It is our responsibility to teach our children responsibilty and the better way to deal with conflicts on all levels. Right now, look at the role models being fostered on all of us. Violence is lauded and even praised as a heroic, patriotic solution. What values are we teaching our children?  
 
I can think of automobiles which causes more deaths within the US than guns. We don\'t blame the vehicles but place it on the drivers. Like the ride, Crazy Cars, there are those that will use it as a weapon. So it is a conditioning that needs change.  
 
There\'s a need to change attitudes (being more respectful, instilling good values regardless of religious beliefs, anger-management,tolerance, and the like; behaviour;habits;even modifying our lifestyle. Being sensitive to others\' feelings is a good start. Empathy instead of apathy. Maybe we should self-examine ourselves honestly and how we relate to others. To the bible-bangers, don\'t bang it; live it through example. It is wiser to take the message and not the messenger. Everything starts within us individually to make good changes.
Guest
Tane

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:



Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.4


Tags:  Jacob G. Hornberger Virginia Tech Gun Control
 
< Prev Content   Next Content >
 

Translate

Enter Amount:


an EffectiveBrand toolbar