Home arrow Commentary arrow OPINIONS arrow op-ed arrow Why Ron Paul's Answer Terrifies Them
May 23 2007
Why Ron Paul's Answer Terrifies Them | Print |  E-mail
Op_ed
By MWC NEWS   

Translation

Why Ron Paul's Answer Terrifies Them
by Jacob G. Hornberger, guest columnist

ImageIn one short answer to a moderator's question in the South Carolina debate in which Republican presidential candidate Ron Paul suggested that U.S. foreign policy motivated the 9/11 terrorists, Paul produced an earthquake that is shaking the Republican establishment.

The chairman of the Michigan Republican Party proposed banning Paul from future debates. Besieged by adverse public reaction, however, he quickly backed down.

FoxNews commentator John Gibson and columnist Michelle Malkin somehow reached the warped conclusion that Paul was suggesting that U.S. officials had committed the 9/11 attacks. After bloggers pointed out the inherent contradiction between that claim and Paul's point that foreign terrorists motivated by U.S. foreign policy had committed the attacks, Malkin quickly issued a retraction.

Other members of the Republican establishment suggested that Paul was "blaming America" for the 9/11 attacks. That's because they think that the federal government is America. Actually, the federal government and the country are composed of two separate and distinct groups of people -- those within the federal government and those within the private sector, a point reflected in the Bill of Rights, which expressly protects the country from the federal government.

What's going on here? Why the enormous, almost panicky, overreaction to what is a rather simple point about U.S. foreign policy? Why the attempts to suppress, distort, and misrepresent? What are they so scared of?

The answer is simple: The Republican establishment knows that if the American people conclude that Ron Paul is right, the jig is up with respect to the big-government, pro-empire, interventionist foreign policy that Republicans (and many Democrats) have supported for many years.

The Republican establishment knows that if the American people conclude that Ron Paul is right, the jig is up with respect to the big-government, pro-empire, interventionist foreign policy that Republicans (and many Democrats) have supported for many years.

Paul's point is a straightforward one: U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East generated the anger that motivated the 9/11 terrorists. If he had had more time, Paul undoubtedly would have pointed out the U.S. policies in the Middle East that made people so angry: (1) the U.S. government's support of Saddam Hussein and the furnishing of biological and chemical weapons of mass destruction to him; (2) the more than 10 years of brutal sanctions against Iraq, which contributed to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Iraqi children; (3) UN Ambassador Madeleine Albright's infamous statement to Sixty Minutes that the deaths of half a million Iraqi children from the sanctions had been "worth it"; (4) the stationing of U.S. troops on Islamic holy lands; (5) the "no-fly zones," which were never authorized by either the UN or the U.S. Congress and which killed still more Iraqis; (6) and the long-time, unconditional financial and military aid provided the Israeli government.

By invading Iraq the U.S. government was engaging in the same course of interventionist conduct that had produced prior acts of terrorism against the United States (not only the 9/11 attacks but the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center, the 1998 terrorist attacks on U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, and the 2000 terrorist attack on the USS Cole). As Paul stated in the debate and as U.S. intelligence agencies confirm, the 2003 invasion of Iraq, which has killed and maimed countless more Iraqis, has been a dream-come-true for Osama bin Laden's recruiters.

The 9/11 terrorist attacks also generated the "war on terror," which in turn has given us ever-increasing budgets for the military-industrial complex, out-of-control federal spending that debauches the currency, omnipotent power to the CIA, an endless stream of color-coded fear-mongering, warrantless monitoring of telephone calls and emails, torture, kidnapping and rendition, secret overseas prison camps, indefinite detention, cancellation of habeas corpus, military tribunals, "enemy combatants," and ever-increasing infringements on civil liberty.

If the U.S. government's foreign policy of interventionism is, in fact, the root cause of terrorism against the United States, there is an obvious solution to the problem: End the U.S. government's role as international policeman, invader, intervener, interloper, provider, and sanctioner. Foreign terrorism against Americans would disappear along with the need for a "war on terror." Civil liberties that were suspended could be restored. A sense of balance and harmony could return to our lives.

Ending interventionism would mean that the era of big government in foreign affairs could be brought to an end. No wonder the Republican establishment is so terrified of Ron Paul's foreign-policy message.


Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org).

Recommend this article...




Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Newsvine!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Quote this article on your site | Views: 9488

Comments (31)
RSS comments
1. 23-05-2007 19:09
Amen. Ron Paul 2008
2. 23-05-2007 19:22
ron paul
Its so obvious our politicians and corporations greed have led to the attacks on the US, you have to be an idiot to have any other answer. The American people are partly to blame for not voting these pricks out.
mgilbo1@yahoo.comNOSPAM! ">Mark Gilbo
3. 23-05-2007 20:29
ron paul
Great article!!! Thanks!
Jose Ortiz
4. 23-05-2007 20:54
ron paul
Ron Paul said that he did not know who exactly orchestrated the 9/11 attacks but what he wants is a new independent investigation. He is a smart guy and he knows damn well that 19 guys with box cutters alone were not responsible for all that append on this sad day.
5. 23-05-2007 20:55
ron paul
The genie is out of the bottle. The neo-cons are pathetically struggling to stuff it back in. Ron Paul's honesty and integrity in the debates has won him favor amongst many many Americans. Regardless if Ron Paul wins or loses, the clock is ticking for the collectivists.
Jim Clark
6. 23-05-2007 21:12
Ron Paul
:grin  
Yes, Ron Paul's honesty has all the others running for cover, and they don't know how to keep up! Time for a rEVOLution: Gotta LOVE Ron Paul!!
7. 23-05-2007 21:16
Ronny is taking them down....
I here few cheers..it's all over...it's all over!
8. 23-05-2007 21:23
Ronny is taking them down....
Dr Paul is the reason I will vote republican for the first time in my life. Hillary or Obama do not have the strength to end the madness. Even though i am a liberal and he is the most conservative congressman, I know he is a man of peace, or the initiator of a new consciousness devoid of partisanship. Maybe the cyclical American revolutionary figure we desperately need to heal the republic.
9. 23-05-2007 21:39
Ronny is taking them down....
Why is this stranglehold on the US citizen/taxpayer nearly impossible to break, this is why: 
http://the-bell-tower.blogspot.com/2007/05/whos-at-wheel.html
gmason@gmail.comNOSPAM! ">G.Mason(author,BillofRights)
10. 23-05-2007 21:59
Ronny is taking them down....
Ooops - the above quote, in bold is from John F. Kennedy, 1962.
11. 23-05-2007 22:01
Ron Paul
It's a cozy little thing: As citizens we don't have to be accountable for the blood on our hands--we depend on our "Commander Guy" to handle our bidding. Of course while he is exporting tyranny to the rest of the world, he is quite successful at vaporizing our liberties with the same thuggery here at home. We've become a frog, being boiled one degree at a time. First rescind Habeas Corpus for terrorists then for you and me. 
 
They can steal elections by sleeping with the MSM. They can't however, steal our thoughts. They know the infectious nature of the truth Ron Paul speaks. That's why they are so trying to keep a lid on it. 
 
Go Ron Paul
12. 23-05-2007 22:16
Ron Paul
"In a time of universal deceit, speaking the truth is a revolutionary act." George Orwell 
 
Long live the revolution!
pharma411@yahoo.comNOSPAM! ">Rob McPherson
13. 23-05-2007 22:34
Ron Paul
Ron Paul will be having a press conference with Michael Scheuer, former head of the CIA's Bin Laden Unit, to discuss flawed American foreign policy and its implications on terrorism, security and Iraq. 
http://npc.press.org/calendar/caldbevent.cfm?eventid=13105
Torchbearer
14. 24-05-2007 06:08
Time to Get behind Ron Paul
I am an unaffiliated registered USA voter who was planning to register DINO so I could vote in the DINO 2008 primary until I watched the RINO debates. Guess who I will back and vote for now.
15. 24-05-2007 07:16
Ron Paul Day - 4th. of July
Let's make Ron Paul the honorary chairman of the United States of America 4th of July celebration. The man deserves it.
bill@thephonegroup.comNOSPAM! ">MI For Ron Paul
16. 24-05-2007 17:35
Ron Paul Day - 4th. of July
Malkin was told she'd be sued for using that student's video without permission of the people who were in it, including me.
NH
17. 26-05-2007 10:27
YOUTUBE numbers...
RON PAUL, RON PAUL, RON PAUL, RON PAUL...that's all I ever hear now days. What's up with his YOUTUBE numbers, eh? The guy's added 7329 new subscribers in less than a week! His GAIN ALONE is 5X more than Rudy's total subscribers; more than twice that of Hillary's, placing him 5635 subscribers ahead of Obama. The only thing going up faster than RON PAUL'S YOU TUBE NUMBER IS THE PRICE OF GAS! Those crazy pimple-faced tech geeks are messin' with the system, I swear. And where does this guy get off telling Rudy G to read books on 9/11 anyways? Doesn't he know that Rudy knows more than ANYONE else about 9/11 - how else do you make $50,000,000 in speaking fees, UNLESS YOU'RE AN EXPERT! What do those guys in the CIA know anyways...Blowback my butt. They messed up when they said we had WMD too. And finally, if anyone brings it up again...that Rudy Giuliani's company represents Fox New's Parent company...I'm going throw a bonafide, 100%, Rudy tantrum!!!
18. 26-05-2007 15:32
re=Rudy G
I enjoyed your web site very much. 
 
:)
Shahram
19. 27-05-2007 04:00
re=Rudy G
well I say it right now, us officials in cia fbi and administartion and armed forces knew of it, and follow the money trail too, they allways profit allways,so what, if he had any brains he would say what he knows is the truth.
sinrancor@msn.comNOSPAM! ">marlin fetuche'
20. 27-05-2007 04:28
re=marlin fetuche
You lost me here. 
 
If who had any brain?
Shahram
21. 27-05-2007 20:40
re=marlin fetuche
poor syntax on my part, i meant if the guy had any guts or wanted to risk assasination he would spill the beans , we all know about 9/11 we aint all asleep here.
sinrancor@msn.comNOSPAM! ">marlin fetuche'
22. 28-05-2007 00:23
re
It's less about having guts then being actually able to prove something. Yes there is many unanswered questions about 9/11. But to accuse someone beyond a reasonable doubt is another story and frankly in my view it would be a political suicide.
Shahram
23. 29-05-2007 19:50
Will Ron Paul & Rudy Giuliani Debate For
Will Ron Paul & Rudy Giuliani Debate Foreign Policy at Freedomfest? 
The annual FreedomFest conference, has issued a debate invitation to GOP Presidential candidates Rudy Giuliani and Ron Paul to use FreedomFest ‘07 as a debate venue to further explore their fundamental differences in foreign policy and the war in Iraq that were highlighted in the Columbia, SC debate. 
http://www.freedomfest.com/debate.htm
ron@freedomfest.comNOSPAM! ">Ron Holland
24. 29-05-2007 21:01
re=Ron
Please let us know if they agree to that.
Shahram
25. 01-06-2007 07:02
re=Ron
Ron Paul is too big to ignore now. Reason has found it's niche. The establishment is on its last leg. Freedom will prevail or it's time to move to the Free State, I'm sure Dr. Paul would follow. But for now, fight like hell for liberty in the US. I got $1000 on it
26. 01-06-2007 12:08
Will Ron Paul & Rudy Giuliani Debate For
Will Ron Paul & Rudy Giuliani Debate Foreign Policy at Freedomfest? 
The annual FreedomFest conference, has issued a debate invitation to GOP Presidential candidates Rudy Giuliani and Ron Paul to use FreedomFest ‘07 as a debate venue to further explore their fundamental differences in foreign policy and the war in Iraq that were highlighted in the Columbia, SC debate. To review the debate invitation - www.freedomfest.com/debate.htm  
For more information on the July 2007 FreedomFest Conference in Las Vegas, go to 
www.freedomfest.com
ron@freedomfest.comNOSPAM! ">Ron Holland
27. 01-06-2007 22:04
Don't forget the oil
Great article. Thanks! I do see another elephant in the room that neither the author here nor even Ron Paul care to talk about, and that is the brutal theft of Iraqi oil. Yes, the bombing, genocide, embargos and such are causing blowback, but we wouldn't even be there if they didn't have oil. We are there to take the oil. That's why we are building 14 permanent military bases and an embassy bigger than the Vatican. Why are we afraid to say it? 
 
http://www.citizensforronpaul.org
Joe
28. 01-06-2007 22:11
Don't forget the oil
Have you read the headline today? 
 
US mulls to... 
 
Is not that their hiding it.
Shahram
29. 02-06-2007 20:34
Letter: Ron Paul 'dangerous to the arro
Letter: Ron Paul 'dangerous to the arrogant pigs' 
 
Quote:
 
Now, the chairman of the Michigan Republican Party, Saul Anuzis, has decided Americans need to be shielded from Paul’s logic, insights and truthfulness. Paul ventured in the last debate that constant U.S. interference in the Middle East provided a major provocation for terrorists ... the very same conclusion the establishment’s own 9/ll Commission arrived at. And yet, Rudolph Giuliani toed the establishment line when he poo-pooed Paul’s thinking as an “absurd explanation.” And now, the chairman of the Michigan GOP says he will try to bar Paul from future GOP debates! 

 
 
Above was published at  
http://www.jg-tc.com/
Shahram
30. 05-06-2007 00:39
Ron Paul Supporters: Where's Giuliani?
Ron Paul Supporters: Where's Giuliani? From www.gambling911.com  
 
http://www.gambling911.com/Ron-Paul-Giuliani-060307.html  
 
Carrie Stroup with Gambling911 has requested the folks at Sportsbook.com - presently offering political betting odds on the 2008 US Presidential election - to offer odds on Giuliani attending and debating Ron Paul at FreedomFest.  
 
Breaking News at 9:34 AM on 6/4/2007 
 
Dr. Paul accepts the invitation to debate Mr. Giuliani. .  
 
Lew Moore 
Campaign Manager 
Ron Paul 2008 PCC 
850 North Randolph Street, Suite 122 
Arlington, VA 22203 
703-248-9115 
 
 
For more information contact: 
Ron Holland,  
FreedomFest Marketing Coordinator 
828 689 2148 ron@freedomfest.com 
 
www.freedomfest.com/debate.htm Paul/Giuliani debate invitation
ron@freedomfest.comNOSPAM! ">Ron Holland
31. 10-06-2007 14:39
Ron Paul Supporters: Where's Giuliani?
I found your comment interesting Joe. I knew the US was considering building permanent military bases, 14 you say? I will take your word for it. I have been thinking for some time it's about the oil. 
Also I believe there is an attempted at some kind of World domination. 
The US has bases all over World, is that to protect us out here? Or are we subjects of Imperial America. 
I wonder. 
 
Mike
1ibis2@excite.comNOSPAM! ">mike keenor

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:



Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.4


Tags:  Jacob G. Hornberger Republican Ron Paul
 
< Prev Content   Next Content >
 

Translate

Enter Amount: