Home arrow Commentary arrow OPINIONS arrow Features arrow So What About Iran?
Sep 28 2007
So What About Iran? | Print |  E-mail
Special Features
By Uri Avnery   
Article Index
So What About Iran?
Page 2

Translation

Ben Heine/ MWC NEWS
Ben Heine/ MWC NEWS
If the American attack turns into a long war of attrition, and if the American public comes to see it as a disaster (as is happening right now with the Iraqi adventure), some will surely put the blame on Israel. It is no secret that the Pro-Israel lobby and its allies - the (mostly Jewish) neo-cons and the Christian Zionists - are pushing America into this war, just as they pushed it into Iraq. For Israeli policy, the hoped-for gains of this war may turn into giant losses - not only for Israel, but also for the American Jewish community.

IF PRESIDENT Mahmoud Ahmadinejad did not exist, the Israeli government would have had to invent him.

He has got almost everything one could wish for in an enemy. He has a big mouth. He is a braggart. He enjoys causing scandals. He is a Holocaust denier. He prophesies that Israel will "vanish from the map" (though he did not say, as falsely reported, the he would wipe Israel off the map.)

"True, the American army is pinned down in Iraq and Afghanistan. Even people like Bush and Cheney could not dream, at this time, of invading a country four times larger than Iraq, with three times the population."

This week, the pro-Israel lobby organized big demonstrations against his visit to New York. They were a huge success - for Ahmadinejad. He has realized his dream of becoming the center of world attention. He has been given the opportunity to voice his arguments against Israel -- some outrageous, some valid - before a world-wide audience.

But Ahmadinejad is not Iran. True, he has won popular elections, but Iran is like the orthodox parties in Israel: it is not their politicians who count, but their rabbis. The Shiite religious leadership makes the decisions and commands the armed forces, and this body is neither boastful nor vociferous not scandal-mongering. It exercises a lot of caution.

If Iran was really so eager to obtain a nuclear bomb, it would have acted in utmost silence and kept as low a profile as possible (as Israel did). The swaggering of Ahmadinejad would hurt this effort more than any enemy of Iran could.

It is highly unpleasant to think about a nuclear bomb in Iranian hands (and, indeed, in any hands.) I hope it can be avoided by offering inducements and/or imposing sanctions. But even if this does not succeed, it would not be the end of the world, nor the end of Israel. In this area, more than in any other, Israel's deterrent power is immense. Even Ahmadinejad will not risk an exchange of queens - the destruction of Iran for the destruction of Israel.

NAPOLEON SAID that to understand a country's policy, one has only to look at the map.

If we do this, we shall see that there is no objective reason for war between Israel and Iran. On the contrary, for a long time it was believed in Jerusalem that the two countries were natural allies.

David Ben-Gurion advocated an "alliance of the periphery". He was convinced that the entire Arab world is the natural enemy of Israel, and that, therefore, allies should be sought on the fringes of the Arab world - Turkey, Iran, Ethiopia, Chad etc. (He also looked for allies inside the Arab world - communities that are not Sunni-Arab, such as the Maronites, the Copts, the Kurds, the Shiites and others.)

At the time of the Shah, very close connections existed between Iran and Israel, some positive, some negative, some outright sinister. The Shah helped to build a pipeline from Eilat to Askelon, in order to transport Iranian oil to the Mediterranean, bypassing the Suez Canal. The Israel internal secret service (Shabak) trained its notorious Iranian counterpart (Savak). Israelis and Iranians acted together in Iraqi Kurdistan, helping the Kurds against their Sunni-Arab oppressors.

The Khomeini revolution did not, in the beginning, put an end to this alliance, it only drove it underground. During the Iran-Iraq war, Israel supplied Iran with arms, on the assumption that anyone fighting Arabs is our friend. At the same time, the Americans supplied arms to Saddam Hussein - one of the rare instances of a clear divergence between Washington and Jerusalem. This was bridged in the Iran-Contra Affair, when the Americans helped Israel to sell arms to the Ayatollahs.

Today, an ideological struggle is raging between the two countries, but it is mainly fought out on the rhetorical and demagogical level. I dare to say that Ahmadinejad doesn't give a fig for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, he only uses it to make friends in the Arab world. If I were a Palestinian, I would not rely on it. Sooner or later, geography will tell and Israeli-Iranian relations will return to what they were - hopefully on a far more positive basis.

ONE THING I am ready to predict with confidence: whoever pushes for war against Iran will come to regret it.

Some adventures are easy to get into but hard to get out of.

The last one to find this out was Saddam Hussein. He thought that it would be a cakewalk - after all, Khomeini had killed off most of the officers, and especially the pilots, of the Shah's military. He believed that one quick Iraqi blow would be enough to bring about the collapse of Iran. He had eight long years of war to regret it.

Both the Americans and we may soon be feeling that the Iraqi mud is like whipped cream compared to the Iranian quagmire.

Recommend this article...




Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Newsvine!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Quote this article on your site | Views: 2187

Comments (4)
RSS comments
1. 29-09-2007 09:29
If Israel starts it and Iran retaliates, it's between Israel and Iran.... If the US comes in and finishes Iran off the whole world will say the US is the aggressor..... 
 
The world is not dumb and stupid as Cheney thinks it is...... Cheney and Bush are the ones that are dumb and stupid..... The whole world knows the aggression that Bush and Cheney did in Iraq and they hate them for it...... 
 
It is Cheney that would think up of a hairbrain idea like that....
Guest
Jac
2. 29-09-2007 15:16
Voices like yours should be heard more often, i am an iranian living in Los Angeles, it's amazing how pro-israeli the media is out here, which is making a lot of people anti-semetic, this was a very impartial and balanced article, 
a lot of people see Jews as people who want another war for the security of Israel, articles like this should be published in papers like the new york times and la times, so people get enlightened and don't "STEREOTYPE".
Guest
3. 30-09-2007 12:58
re=
Quote:
 
articles like this should be published in papers like the new york times and la times, so people get enlightened and don't "STEREOTYPE". 

 
 
That would be the day. :)  
 
Thanks for the comment.
Guest
Shahram
4. 09-10-2007 14:48
re=
If Israel starts it and Iran retaliates The world knows of the quest to control the oil. The world hates Americans for their policie's and the coalition of the willing including Israel lobby. The world knows and their goverments still support! What are their people and even knowing Americans going to do about it. Many still think Iraq is about installing a working democracy, the word stooge is missing except when it comes to the puppet Maliki and his puppet brothers in Lebanon and Afghanistan. The signed on industrial countries continue to push their peoples to stretch their limits, and their people in power in the banks and governments, continue their support for aggression, evidenced in their silence, Merkels lately comes to mind. Canada, Mexico and France are signing in as they have their individual internal terroism programs beggining. The goverments and THOSE WHO OWN THEM are positioning themselfs. Not about Bush leaving office, more about getting as much energy control and or blocking others aquiring energy control, before to much upheaval builds in all countries populace. The wealthy owners in major media outlets support captured control of the world markets thru energy control. Prefering people stay as far from the real truth as possible.
Guest

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:

Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.4


Tags:  Uri Avnery Dick Cheney Iran


 
< Prev Content   Next Content >
 

Translate

Enter Amount: