Home arrow Commentary arrow Editorial arrow Passive Genocide by Burma Junta & US Alliance
May 21 2008
Passive Genocide by Burma Junta & US Alliance | Print |  E-mail
Editorial
By Gideon Polya   

Translation

Mass Killing by US Empire & MyanmarImage

Western Mainstream media, Governments and politicians very properly condemn passive mass murder in cyclone-devastated Burma by the insufficiently responsive Burma military junta – but are highly hypocritical in ignoring the horrendous passive killing by US Alliance military occupiers in the US Empire from Occupied Haiti to Occupied Afghanistan.

Cyclone Nargis has devastated the Irrawaddy delta of Myanmar (Burma) – it is estimated that 130,000 are dead or missing and that about 2 million urgently require aid (shelter, food, water, medicine and medical attention). UN and Aid organization officials are very properly highly critical of the tardiness of the Burma military junta in relation to permitting foreign aid workers to enter Burma.

Indeed utterly irresponsible Western war-mongers have suggested "war" as a solution to the humanitarian crisis in Burma (e.g. war-mongering suggestions by the war criminal French Government, the war criminal UK Government and former Ministers in the extreme right-wing, war criminal, former Bush-ite Australian Federal Government).

However the patently obvious solutions to the Myanmar military junta intransigence over requisite urgent aid delivery to the Irrawaddy delta   involve (a) offers of irresistably massive assistance to be urgently delivered by Myanmar’s Asean neighbours (indeed the Burma junta has now agreed to Asean-delivered aid), and (b) collective international promise of International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutions and targetted Sanctions for all those substantially involved in any major, active or passive human rights abuses.

An important outcome of the ongoing Myanmar tragedy is effective international recognition of the concept of “passive mass murder” (“passive mass killing”, “passive murder”, “passive killing”) – although racist, lying, holocaust-ignoring Mainstream media in the Western Murdochracies do not actually use this terminology (a Google search for use of these phrases in the context of Burma elicited almost no URLs).

At some point “passive mass murder” by unresponsive régimes or foreign occupiers can be seen as “passive genocide” i.e. genocide effected passively by the Ruler by withholding requisite life-sustaining food and medicine. “Genocide” in this context is as defined by Article 2 of the UN Genocide Convention:

“In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such:

a) Killing members of the group;
b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.”


“Intent” to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group is very rarely conceded by the mass murderers themselves (they know that mass murder  is wrong and severely punishable) but is readily established empirically by evidence of

(a) sustained , remorseless, active or passive  policy resulting in
(b) mass mortality in a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.

Indeed a Google Search reveals that several commentators (in Alternative media of course) have now actually used the phrase “passive genocide” in relation to the passivity of the Burma junta in the face of the Cyclone Nargis catastrophe. The term “passive genocide” has been employed in relation to other catastrophes involving horrendous non-violent as well as violent deaths, notably the ongoing Palestinian, Iraqi, Afghan, Biofuel and Climate Genocides (for details of horrendous past and continuing “active genocide” and “passive genocide” in which my own country, Australia, is complicit together with its Anglo-American allies see MWC News).

It is useful to compare the catastrophic situation in Mynamar (Burma) under the brutal military junta with the situation in Occupied Iraq and Occupied Afghanistan under the heel of the US Alliance military.

Thus WHO data indicate that "annual total per capita medical expenditure" and "under-5 infant deaths per 1,000 live births" are $38 and 104, respectively in Myanmar (Burma) as compared to $19 and 257, respectively, in Australia-, France-, UK-, US-, and NATO-US Alliance-occupied Afghanistan and $130 and 47 in Occupied Iraq versus $3,123 and 6 (Australia), $3,040 and 5 (France), $2,560 and 6 (UK), and $6,096 and 8 ( USA) (evidence of “passive genocide” and gross violation of the Geneva Convention by the US, UK, NATO and Australia). Image

In Myanmar 2 million urgently need aid and 130,000 are already dead or missing. According to UNICEF data in Occupied Afghanistan 327,000 infants die each year, corresponding roughly to 327,000/0.7 = 467,000 total annual avoidable Occupied Afghan deaths from deprivation (for impoverished Third World countries, infant deaths/total excess deaths = 0.7;  see “Layperson’s guide to counting Iraq deaths” on MWC News). A similar calculation from UN data for Occupied Iraq yields an estimate of average annual post-invasion avoidable deaths from deprivation in Occupied Iraq totalling 160,000 per year.

Of course Occupied Afghanistan and Occupied Iraq are also subject to horrendous civilian-targetting violence by the US Alliance military and estimates for Occupied Iraq suggest that annual violent avoidable deaths in both war zones are roughly the same as annual non-violent avoidable deaths (see “Iraq Invasion 5th Anniversary” on MWC News).

Another way of estimating “passive genocide” is by estimating the “annual non-violent avoidable death rate” as a percentage i.e. the number out of every 100 who die avoidably each year: 2.0% (Indigenous Aboriginal Australians in the Northern Territory); 1.8% (Indigenous Aboriginal Australians as a whole); 1.6% (for US Alliance- and Australia-occupied Occupied Afghanistan); 1.0% (non-Arab Africa); 0.7% (Myanmar; 2003); 0.6% (for US Alliance- and Australia-occupied Occupied Iraq); and 0% (for China, Japan, North America, Australasia, Apartheid Israel and Western Europe).

Myanmar has a population of 48 million (2006) and if we assume for the purposes of argument that 100,000 Burmese die as a result of Burma military junta passivity and intransigence then the “annual avoidable death rate” for 2008 will climb to 0.9%, absolutely appalling but still much lower than that for Indigenous Australians or for US Alliance subjects in the Occupied Iraqi and Afghan Territories.

The World pressure for Burma junta acceptance of Asean-delivered aid to Myanmar has finally succeeded and one desperately hopes that the deaths from deprivation and deprivation-exacerbated disease will now be contained. However the magnitude of the Burma junta’s “passive genocide” in cyclone-devastated Burma must be assessed and the culprits arraigned before the International Criminal Court.  The same judicial process must also be applied to the governments involved in the active and passive genocide in Occupied Iraq and Occupied Afghanistan.

The Burma tragedy-impelled recognition by Mainstream media and politicians of the concepts – if not the terminology - of “passive genocide” and “passive mass murder” is a remarkable first step to global cessation of these horrendous atrocities and judicial arraignment of the guilty to ensure that this will never happen again to any people.

Dr Gideon Polya,  MWC News Chief political editor, published some 130 works in a 4 decade scientific career, most recently a huge pharmacological reference text "Biochemical Targets of Plant Bioactive Compounds" (CRC Press/Taylor & Francis, New York & London, 2003), and is currently writing a book on global mortality ---
Other articles by this author 


This_Category
Category:: Editorial

Recommend this article...




Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Newsvine!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Quote this article on your site | Views: 3424

Comments (6)
RSS comments
1. 21-05-2008 20:51
Do you really know how difficult to live under this dictatorship which the world does not really see as bad as it is? It's a country without future...like myself who did not have nth much to do unless work with the junta or go abroad...and I feel that any foreign invasion will be better than the silence death or prosecution happening under the opaque government... I believe the US and its alliance's passive killings seems higher as burma's junta never release those numbers and the international community never have or little desire to know... And it's unfair to compare burma and iraq cuz we have different situation...We are in South East Asia, not Middle East, We are Buddhists, not where extremists live... We have a leader, Aung San Suu Kyi whom everyone relied on and believed...We all have desire to attain democracy and We did demand for it...It's just that we need help and pressure to force this junta realize what it really should be doing... 
Thank you.
Guest
2. 21-05-2008 22:34
Burma & US passive genocide
Like all decent folk I am utterly appalled by the brutal military subjugation of Burma, the imprisonment of their overwhelmingly democratically-elected leader and Nobel Laureate Aung San Suu Kyi and now the passive genocide in the aftermath of Cyclone Nargis. 
 
However PEACE is the only way - the solutions lie in (a) massive aid urgently delivered by ASEAN countries and (b) resolute International action via ICC prosecutions and targetted Sanctions against the Burma junta and ALL complicit governments, corporations and individuals. 
 
Many Iraqis no doubt welcomed the demise of Saddam Hussein but over 5 years later the dimensions of the Iraqi Holocaust, the Iraqi Genocide (by the 5th anniversary of invasion 1.7-2.2 million post-invasion excess deaths, about half of them VIOLENT excess deaths: Iraqi Genocide) is testament to HOW the US and its European allies conduct high technology, civilian-targetting warfare to minimize Anglo-American military casualties by causing huge civilian deaths. 
 
Excess mortality (avoidable mortality, excess death, avoidable death, deaths that did not have happen) is huge in Myanmar (in 2003, about 350,000 died avoidably; see: Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950). 
 
Massive, urgent International pressure is needed to stop this passive genocide in Myanmar, the US Empire and in a swathe of Third World countries subject to remorseless First World economic hegemony (16 million people die avoidably each year due to deprivation and deprivation-exacerbated disease but this is set to rise due to the biofuel perversion, global warming and huge global food price rises: Biofuel famine, biofuel genocide and the global food price crisis - Climate Emergency, Sustainability Emergency).
Guest
gpolya@bigpond.comNOSPAM! ">Dr Gideon Polya
3. 22-05-2008 04:38
Not enoug food for Cyclone hit area
Very poor, even they did't get any biscuit from Aid, How should we do? Aid go direct to hit area. Help Burma not Junta.
Guest
4. 22-05-2008 08:39
Not enoug food for Cyclone hit area
a) Asean holds the meeting only two weeks after the cyclone when critics points out if there is still relevence...I wonder even if they have desire to do this...Asean has only policies and they are not enforced...The most disturbing is that they are trying to sign the human right charter which Burma's general cannot follow at all while abusing its citizens...The group's constructive engagement is not working at all to change the situation in burma...it's been 11 years Burma is in the group...and i believe this will also follow the faith of US sanctions without much effect on the general... 
b)ICC prosecution is possible but sanctions are only effective when all the countries impose...Myanmar generals have China and Russia to veto any resolutions in UNSC...It is unlikey for China not to veto as Burma has biggest natural gas reserve which it wants... 
 
sigh...It seems burma has no hope... :cry unless all the people rise up again and win or die and extinct under those inhumane general....
Guest
5. 23-05-2008 12:56
Not enoug food for Cyclone hit area
My division will soon be marching into Rangoon 
and I will have General Than Shwe's head mounted on my wall. 
 
Give me the sign 
I'm waiting to pull the trigger. 
 
The Burmese Army and people have promise me his head 
and I want to take it.
Guest
6. 23-05-2008 22:04
Child-killing US war obscenity
The calls for Western (i.e. US) military intervention to \"solve\" the humanitarian crisis in Myanmar are utterly obscene.  
 
The US high technology warfare strategies since World War 2 (firebombing cities, atomic bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki) have involved deliberately targetting civilians to minimize US casualties and hence loss of domestic VOTES.  
 
Thus in post-1950 US Asian wars the excess deaths have totalled 25 million with about 50% of the dead being CHILDREN and about three quarters WOMEN AND CHILDREN. 
 
The facts of evil, dishonest, violent, civilian tragetting US interventions around the world have been summarized by Wiliam Bllum in \"Rogue State\". The appalling human cost is summarized in \"Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950\"
 
Of course the active and passive killing does not stop when the yellow, woman- and child-killing US military leave the devastated countries - thus the 1950-2005 excess deaths in countries violently occupied the US as a major occupier in the post-war era (excluding Germany and Japan) total 82 million - about the same death toll as for both Eastern and Western theatres of World War 2.  
 
Just as the last Nazis are still being hunted down around the world for the murder of civilians so YELLOW US and US Alliance child- and woman-killers should be arrested, arraigned, tried and punished wherever they are found on Planet Earth - these are no more \"soldiers\" than Concentration Camp guards in Auschwitz. 
 
Indeed, while the \"enemy civilian/occupier military\" death ratio as advocated by Hitler was 10 and the ratio actually \"realized\" by evil Nazi Germany in WW2 was 11, the \"enemy civilian/US military\" death ratio in WW2 was about 17 - however it has steadily climbed to be about 2,000,000/4,000 = 250 (Iraq War, 2003-2008) and a truly shocking value as high as 7,000,000/500 = 14,000 (Afghanistan war, 2001-2008). 
 
The US Alliance perpetrators need to be subject to international and intra-national SANCTIONS until (a) all the culprits have been arrested, arraigned, tried and punished by the International Criminal Court and (b) the the post-1945, post-Holocaust protocol of the defeated Germans is adopted, namely CAAAA (C4A) involving Cessation of the killing, Acknowlegdement of the crimes, Apology, Amends, and Assertion \"never again to anyone\" .
Guest
gpolya@bigpond.comNOSPAM! ">Dr Gideon Polya

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:

Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.4


Tags:  Gideon Polya Passive Genocide Burma Junta US Alliance Myanmar
 
< Prev Content   Next Content >
 

Translate

Enter Amount: