Saturday, May 26, 2018
Text Size

Site Search powered by Ajax

Gaza Facts: Israel Is Wrong, Period


by M.J. Rosenberg

Listening to Netanyahu's defenders in the media (and that is pretty much all you get as objective reporters are yanked off the air), I'm struck by how Americans are indoctrinated into ignoring the most significant fact about Gaza.

It is under Israeli occupation (now called blockade) and has been since 1967.

That is the cause of the "war." Yes, Israel has the "right" to defend itself but Palestinians have the "right" to resist occupation. Those conflicting rights are leading to perdition and, in my opinion, the loss of the Israel many of us have loved and identified with our entire lives. 

The oft-proclaimed Gaza withdrawal was a fraud. Although Israel pulled the settlers out, it has maintained a blockade of Gaza ever since, blocking its air, sea, and land borders, locking its people in a giant prison. 

At the time Ariel Sharon withdrew the settlers, when the Palestinian Authority was still in charge of Gaza, he refused to coordinate Israel's withdrawal with Mahmoud Abbas who, despite his pleas, was not even told when the pullout would take place. Abbas wanted to ensure that the militants (who he effectively subdued in the West Bank) would not seize control. Sharon refused and the militants took over. 

Then there were the democratic elections of 2006. The United States said it would abide by the results of the election but, once the results came in and Hamas won ("free and fair" according to US election monitors), the United States joined Israel to do everything in its power to overturn the results.  

Ultimately Gaza separated from the West Bank and Israel was free to enter Gaza at will, killing or imprisoning whoever it considered a threat, and, in the process, hundreds who weren't. Militants launched rockets at Israel and Israel responded, disproportionately as always. As now.

As this New York Times piece from earlier this week demonstrates, this latest onslaught was produced by Netanyahu's determination to destroy the Palestinian unity agreement, a goal he convinced the U.S. and Europe to embrace.  The reason Netanyahu needed to destroy Palestinian unity was his fear that Hamas would allow President Abbas to negotiate with Israel on behalf of all Palestinians, leading to a peace agreement (i.e., the end of the occupation.)  

JJ Goldberg, editor of the Jewish Forward reports here how Netanyahu, knowing that the kidnapped Israeli teenagers were dead from day 1, maintained the fiction they were alive for 18 days in order to ignite the atmosphere for war. He even lied to the boys' parents. 

Of course, this is the Netanyahu who presided at demonstrations in Israel in 1995 at which Yitzhak Rabin was depicted as a Nazi and his death was demanded. Rabin's widow, Leah, believed Netanyahu incited her husband's assassination. You may recall that while Mrs. Rabin welcomed Yasir Arafat into her home after her husband's murder, she banned Netanyahu.  

Is this irrelevant now? No, not when the current situation directly stems from the murder of the one Israeli leader determined to achieve peace with the Palestinians. Netanyahu's rise is the direct result of Rabin's murder. 

Bottom line: this war is the result of the occupation in general and specifically the suppression of the people of Gaza. It is a result of Netanyahu's deceptions and his determination to never give up a single inch of land. Although firing rockets at Israeli civilians is intolerable, it is easy to understand why the militants do it. They are imprisoned. And they are desperate. (Imagine how Jews would feel if little Israeli boys were blown up on the beach in broad daylight and even Barack Obama could not muster a word of sympathy, lest he offend a lobby). 

My fellow Jews who support this war are entitled to. But they should not kid themselves. They are supporting Netanyahu for one reason alone: ethnic solidarity. Just like every other nation on earth that cheered wars sold to them by liars. Fine. But that is all it is. The cause of the war is the occupation and Israel's adamant refusal to end it. How long will we be duped? 

My solution: it was stated by Avraham Shapiro, the former head of the Shin Beth, in the film GATEKEEPERS. He said "talk to them. Talk to them all." But, of course, Shapiro, like most of Israel's intelligence community, is naive. Only war works. This war will really show 'em. 

The following is an email I received from a Middle East expert I worked with at Israel Policy Forum, Steve Warnecke. Check it out: 

Questions that don't exist for Congress and the media.

        1. What has made the Gazans so enraged against Israel that they are prepared to suffer so much destruction and suffering?

        2. If there had been no occupation that transmuted into imprisonment, there would have been no rockets being shot at Israel.

        3. For many years Gaza has been surrounded by an army, air force and naval cordon that have intermittently shelled an area two times the size of Washington.

        4. There have been six Israeli invasions of Gaza justified by the rockets and the existence of Hamas.

        5. Why did Israel use these intrusions to destroy Gaza's electricity, gas and sewage systems causing a devastation crisis for 1.8 million people. This hardly describes Israel's destruction that had nothing to do with Hamas or rocketeers.

        6. Where did the Israeli-designated terrorists come from. In 1948 750,000 Palestinians were forced to leave the Israel of that time. Their property was seized and 450 villages bull-dozen so they would have no place to which they could return. Very quickly passed a law forbidding them the right to return. Israel felt no responsibility for the horrors they inflicted on the Palestinians.

        7. Hundreds of thousands of the disposed living in detestable refugee camps.

       8. The reservoir of recruits was expanded in 1967 when two hundred thousand West Bankers fled before the advancing Israeli forces.

       9. Recruits came from the destruction of their residences, victims of Israel's bull-dozing their homes, the vicious operations of the IDF, border police and Shin Bet as from among those who were put in indefinite "administrative detention" or imprisoned.
      10. Israel's manipulated narrative has included successfully branding the Palestinians as terrorists, when they have been simply trying to free themselves from first an occupation and then a blockade. They are the victims here.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Subscribe via RSS or Email:

The Abused Jews of Iraq

From April 1950, nearly two ...

Read More

The U.S. and Israel are marching towards War with Iran

On Monday, May 21, Secretary...

Read More

Trump's threats are empowering hardliners in Iran

Mike Pompeo's 12 demands from ...

Read More

The Day of Shame

On bloody Monday this week, ...

Read More

Shabbos with Zaide

The surrealism of this week’...

Read More

Time to End Foreign Aid to Israel

Given the recent shooting of...

Read More


Thanks to all of our supporters for your generosity and your encouragement of an independent press!

Enter Amount:



Login reminder Forgot login?


Subscribe to MWC News Alert

Email Address

Subscribe in a reader Facebok page Twitter page

Week in Pictures

Ramadan begins

Palestinians in Gaza 'massacre'