Sunday, May 19, 2019
Text Size

Site Search powered by Ajax

Chile not obliged to negotiate sea access with Bolivia: ICJ

Ruling frustrates hopes to resolve a bitter 135-year dispute between the two Latin American neighbours.

An international court has ruled that Chile does not have to negotiate access to the Pacific Ocean with Bolivia, frustrating hopes of resolving a bitter 135-year dispute.

The International Court of Justice (ICJ), based in The Hague, handed down the decision on Monday, with judges voting 12-3 that Chile cannot be forced into dialogue with its Andean neighbour. 

"The court [...] finds that the Republic of Chile did not undertake a legal obligation to negotiate a sovereign access to the Pacific ocean with the Plurinational State of Bolivia," said ICJ President Judge Abdulqawi Ahmed Yusuf.

Landlocked Bolivia lost access to the Pacific following a war with Chile in the late 1800s. Already one of the poorest countries in Latin America, Bolivia says the lack of sea access has hampered its economic growth. 

Bolivia has long argued that Chile has been ducking legal obligations to enter negotiations that are outlined in resolutions from the Organization of American States (OAS).

Chile, however, says the issue was resolved by a 1904 peace treaty between the two countries and points out that Bolivia already has duty-free access to the Chilean port of Arica. 

Monday's judgement said that OAS resolutions are not legally binding under international law and that talks so far held between the two countries on creating a corridor to the ocean do not compel Chile to actually create such a corridor. 

Celebration and sadness

Speaking at a press conference after the ruling, Chilean President Sebastian Pinera celebrated the "great triumph of the Chilean cause" in front of a crowd who chanted "Viva Chile".

Pinera said his country has always had an "attitude of reconciliation" towards all others, particularly their neighbours, but that Chile would always defend its sovereignty. 

He once again accused Bolivia's President Evo Morales, who is seeking a controversial fourth term, of using the territorial dispute to drum up support at home.

Pinera said Chile "has never had any obligation" to negotiate sea access and that Morales had given Bolivians "false expectations". 

For his part, Morales said Bolivia would "never withdraw" its claim to the sea and that the two countries and the rest of the region have a responsibility to resolve the dispute, regardless of Monday's ruling. 

The issue is strongly felt on both sides of the border, with Chilean and Bolivian networks broadcasting the ICJ ruling live.

TRANSLATION: Bolivia accepts The Hague's ruling with calm and prudence. The conclusion of 12 judges does not cancel out the feelings of 10 million Bolivians. Bolivia - now and forever - will not stop looking for a political agreement that allows it to have a presence in the sea.

In schools, Bolivian children sing songs about the country's return to the sea, while Chile celebrates its victory in the war against Bolivia with a national holiday.

"The sea is a decisive factor for development and prosperity of people and nations," said Claudio Gutierrez, a philosophy professor a member of Mar Para Bolivia, a group of Chileans who support Bolivia's claim to the sea. 

"Supporting Bolivia is necessary for the brotherhood of South Americans and to heal the damage and injustice that has been done to Bolivia by depriving it of an entryway and direct exit to the sea, which [would allow] it to communicate with the world," he said.

The long-simmering dispute boiled over in 2013 after Bolivia filed a lawsuit with the ICJ, which settles legal disputes between UN member states, in an attempt to force Chile to negotiate sea access. 

Chile annexed Bolivia's 380km coastline in 1884 after the War of the Pacific, leaving Bolivia landlocked. 

The row has poisoned diplomatic relations between the two countries, which have not hosted each other's ambassadors for decades. 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Subscribe via RSS or Email:

Wildfires deadliest on record in Ca...

Read More

California wildfires death toll at ...

Read More

California wildfires: Death toll ri...

Read More

Raging California wildfires kill 9,...

Read More

Brazil landslide: At least 10 dead ...

Read More

Florida orders recount in contentio...

Read More

Most Read Articles

Most Read News


Thanks to all of our supporters for your generosity and your encouragement of an independent press!

Enter Amount:



Login reminder Forgot login?

Subscribe to MWC News Alert

Email Address

Subscribe in a reader Facebok page Twitter page

Israel pounds Gaza

India's Kerala state devastated

Capturing life under apartheid